Listen
Case file
EP 08

From Lying to the FBI to Helping Targets Avoid His Mistakes

Justin Paperny

File
EP 08
Date
12 Nov 2026
Length
58 min
0:0057:41

Show notes

Justin Paperny was fired from UBS in January 2005 and escorted out of his office. Two weeks later, at 7 a.m. on a Saturday, his biggest client called him from an office line instead of his cell phone and asked him to explain things again. Justin was sure the call was being recorded. He kept talking anyway, hoping whoever was listening would hear that he’d done nothing wrong.

Two months later, an FBI agent and an IRS agent showed up at his door. When he sat down with the FBI, he lied. He lied to his parents about why he left his career, and he told his own lawyers half-truths. He was sentenced to 18 months in federal prison and surrendered three years to the day after the agents came to his house. On his second day inside, Michael Santos, who had already served 22 years, told him, “I’ll serve every day of that sentence with you.”

Justin sits down with Alex Little and Amy Nelson on the Season 1 finale of TARGET to talk about the call he should have hung up on, why he couldn’t tell his lawyers the truth, what Santos taught him in prison, and how he built White Collar Advice and the nonprofit Prison Professors to help people facing what he faced.

Timestamps

  1. 00:00Cold open
  2. 00:59Justin Paperny
  3. 01:29Meeting on TikTok
  4. 01:56“I went totally dark”
  5. 02:48Fired from UBS
  6. 03:59A recorded phone call
  7. 05:18Talking his way into more trouble
  8. 06:44The FBI at his door
  9. 07:18“May I call a lawyer?”
  10. 08:34Lying to his parents
  11. 09:17Keeping the money coming in
  12. 10:33Keeping up the facade
  13. 12:01Lying to his own lawyers
  14. 13:10“If you think it’s bad, share it”
  15. 14:51What the FBI already knew
  16. 15:57Not knowing it was a crime
  17. 17:18Willful blindness
  18. 18:06The fax that came too late
  19. 19:041,500 sentencing hearings
  20. 20:31Truth-tellers
  21. 21:06Finding the right lawyers
  22. 23:12What he does now
  23. 23:34Sentenced to 18 months
  24. 24:51Michael Santos and the first blog
  25. 27:41White Collar Advice
  26. 28:06How prosecutors see you
  27. 29:29No one can promise an outcome
  28. 30:27Was the effort wasted?
  29. 31:04When you’re wrongly accused
  30. 31:59Ninety trials and no wins
  31. 33:36P.G. Sittenfeld
  32. 34:13When someone else writes your story
  33. 35:19“I should have gone to trial”
  34. 37:02When prosecutors charge the spouse
  35. 37:34The don’t-charge-the-girlfriend rule
  36. 38:46What should change
  37. 39:22Copying Michael Santos’ letter
  38. 41:09You can’t fake remorse
  39. 41:59Lawyers who won’t listen
  40. 43:45It doesn’t end at sentencing
  41. 44:38Starting the work early
  42. 46:19Making better choices every day
  43. 47:00What a prison consultant won’t do
  44. 48:43“What could that person be someday?”
  45. 50:28Book reports in prison
  46. 51:26“You’re a tourist”
  47. 52:51Working with people others write off
  48. 53:43Jimmy Carter and the warlords
  49. 55:11Not through talk
  50. 55:33Thrown out of law offices

Transcript

Read the full transcript

Amy: Welcome to TARGET, Justin.

Justin: Thank you. I’m grateful to be here.

Amy: Today we are with Justin Paperny, who I have known for a number of years and whose story I’m excited to dig into.

Justin: I met you through TikTok when you were speaking so openly about your experience and then someone left a comment that said, “You should know Amy Nelson.” I said, “Who is that?” And then I looked, and I followed and commented, and then we connected, so it was good old TikTok.

Amy: It was good old TikTok. And I think the power of becoming internet friends on social media, like, you really helped me understand parts of a system that seemed completely opaque to me, which is something that you’ve really built a career around.

Justin: Well, some of my initial comments were, I said, “I admire you because you’re responding to this investigation so differently than I did when I was a target.” So when I was a target, I didn’t accept responsibility. I blamed other people. I would sit in my home all day and chew tobacco to the point where my teeth would bleed. And every time I would get an email from my lawyer, I’d, like, freak out. Like, I needed, like, 30 or 40 minutes before I could open it. I didn’t go to Mother’s Day or Father’s Day ’cause everyone would ask, like, “Hey, dude. What’s happening?” I’m like, “I don’t wanna talk to anyone.” I went totally dark, and then I saw how you responded openly, sharing lessons, the vulnerability. We’re broke. We’re moving. They’ve taken everything. This is what we’re doing. I still have an obligation to be a mom. And I’m like, that is how you respond to crisis. So that was the connection and why I admired you so much.

Amy: Why, thank you. Well, let’s take you back 24 years.

Justin: Yes. I was fired from UBS January 2005 from my role, and really in bad conduct that started at Bear Stearns and then continued into my time at UBS. And then I was escorted by two huge dudes out of my office in Century City. And they walked me down to my car. I had just been fired, and that’s when, really, the cultivation of, like, bad decisions over a number of years, I was beginning to pay the price for it. But at the time, ’cause I didn’t know anyone who had been to prison, I grew up with a lot of opportunity and knowing right from wrong. The only one who’d ever gone to jail in my town was Michael Milken from Encino. But nobody knew Michael Milken, right? So I’m like, all right, this is as bad as it’s gonna get. I’m going to get fired, but I’m 30. I have some resources. I have a brain. I’m gonna figure it out. I didn’t realize that, like, every decision I was beginning to make as a target was making matters worse for me, and I was building a record that sort of confirmed how the government perceived me, that this is a bad dude that blames other people, that doesn’t care that he hurt people. It was really a fixation on Justin and how my own life is falling apart, so it started in 2005.

Alex: What was the first moment, though, when you realized this wasn’t just, “I’m gonna get fired. I may need to get another job,” but, “I’m under investigation by the federal government”?

Justin: So about two weeks after I was fired from UBS, I received a phone call from what eventually turned out to be my co-defendant. It’s like, that’s surreal to say. It was at 7 a.m. on a Saturday. I was at my friend Sam Pompeo’s home in Calabasas. And any time my former client, who was a hedge fund manager, would call me, it would be from his cell phone, a 661 area code in Valencia. Instead, it was his office phone. And I picked up, and because I had worked with him for so long, I knew that something was afoot, and he was beginning to ask me questions. And I’m like, “I think this is a recorded line.”

Amy: Wow. You immediately thought that.

Alex: So imagine, you know, we’re married, right? You speak with your spouse 1,000 times, someone you work with thousands of times, and suddenly there’s a different conversation. Like, there are times my wife calls me and I’m like, “What’s wrong?” You just know.

Justin: I knew something was wrong.

Alex: Different phone number, totally odd topics.

Justin: Different tone. Like, “Hey, help me understand this again,” working with this guy. And I’m like, “All right, something’s wrong.” And rather than hang up the phone, I’m like, “All right, this is an opportunity to help myself.” This is the opportunity that I need to ensure these FBI agents who are listening can realize Justin Matthew Paperny did nothing wrong, and we can get on with our day now.

Alex: It’s such a problem with white collar defendants, that they just think they can just explain their way out of anything.

Justin: I thought I could talk my way out of it. They would see that I was simply the broker who executed trades on an unsolicited basis, who went to UBS to disclose the heavy losses in commissions, that we were all a team and we were gonna support each other. Of course, I didn’t realize UBS has their own agenda. Right? They’re cooperating. They’re giving information to the government. My senior partner did as well. He was wise. He lawyered up. I didn’t. I just figured they’d see that I was younger. I executed the trades. I didn’t manage the money. And I didn’t do what we would encourage people in our community to do, which is it probably makes sense not just to hire a great lawyer and vet a lawyer, but invest the time to sort of understand, like, how this happened. Because it’s not enough to say, “I didn’t have bad intentions.” Judge Carter at a sentencing hearing one time told a defendant, “I’m not concerned about your intentions. I’m concerned about the results with the victims here in the front row.” And it’s like, oh wow, that would’ve been helpful. This service that I lead didn’t exist then. So I just talked my way into more trouble. And eventually, the FBI agent with whom I had become very close said, “In a way, that could be construed as obstruction, because you were deliberately trying to impede and obstruct an investigation.” I’m like, “I was just trying to help myself.”

Alex: Now, you thought you knew at that time, “Okay, I think FBI is listening.” When was that confirmed to you? How quickly did you go from, “There’s a really odd phone call with this person who’s going to be your co-defendant,” to, “The FBI shows up at my door,” or, “My lawyer gets a letter”? Kind of what’s the next step in that for you?

Justin: April 20th, 2005, about two months later, Agent Paul Bertrand showed up at my front door, walks in with binders. And he has the whole FBI gear on. I joke with him. I’m like, “The hat, the jacket, the pants.” It’s like, everyone knows you work for the FBI. He walks in with all of the binders. My little dog is freaking out. And of course, I had lost my job. I’m figuring out what I’m going to do next. I’m just sitting at home in despair, like, “What did I do?”

Amy: What time of day is this?

Justin: Middle of the day.

Alex: Is it just him, or did he have a partner with him?

Justin: They always come in pairs, I learned, so it was actually, like, an IRS agent who tagged along with him. So they come in pairs.

Amy: So you’ve got two agencies.

Justin: There’s two agents in there. And they said, “We’d like to talk to you about your role in the GLT Venture Fund.” And I’m like, I’m really caught off guard. I said, “What would you like to talk about?” And then he pulls out a piece of paper. And then a part of me is like, all right, I’m not stupid. My mom was a paralegal for more than 30 years with some really wonderful lawyers. I know I’m supposed to have a lawyer. So I said, “Agent Bertrand, may I call a lawyer?” He said, “Sure.” So I called a civil lawyer. Because the lawsuits from investors through my client’s hedge fund had begun to come in. So the first lawyer I called said, “Look, UBS…” And this gave me comfort that I wish I didn’t hear. He said, “UBS will eventually settle with every investor. They’re culpable, I believe, based on what you’ve told me. So you hire me, you’ll probably end up having to cover my legal fees, but UBS is gonna scratch the check.” Now, that ultimately happened. All of the investors were paid back, but it didn’t change. Hearing that kinda gave me the warm and fuzzies, like, “Hey, this is gonna be UBS.”

Alex: Oh, it’s gonna be all right.

Justin: So I hire this civil lawyer. He gets on the phone with the agent, and we have our interview with the FBI one month to the day later at his office in the San Fernando Valley.

Amy: Tell me about the two months between the weird phone call on Saturday morning and the agents showing up. Did you, like, did you just go about your life? Did you think about calling a lawyer then?

Justin: I lied. I did what so many good people in crisis do. They double down. They don’t think, “How can I stop the bleeding? How can I begin to build some narrative that might be different than the government’s version of events?” So if the government’s working full time to advance their agenda with our tax dollars, it might make sense that a defendant begins to build. But I didn’t do that, so I would lie to my parents and say I chose to leave my career as a stockbroker. And my mom’s not stupid. She’d say, “Well, you’re the youngest broker that Bear Stearns hired at 26. Why would you then, two years later, leave that role? It doesn’t make sense to me.” But I think as a mother, she just listened and empathized the best she could. My dad didn’t say much. So I lied to my parents that I chose to leave, and I was gonna begin to build a career in real estate.

Amy: So you were just completely pivoting.

Justin: Yes. I pretty quickly got my real estate license, and I ended up selling real estate for three years in Calabasas at Sotheby’s before I went to prison. But then I was kind of scheming with my former senior partner, who said to me, “Look, you’re gonna need to make money. So what you need to do for the book of business that you manage,” it was professional baseball players and some hedge fund clients where I executed trades. He’s like, “You need clients that you manage to stay. And if they do, I’m gonna give you a percentage of those revenues.” So then I would spend some of my days calling clients like, “Hey, I moved on, but Ken is still gonna take very good care of you.” And I was thinking not about, like, how do I manage a potential investigation, but rather how can I continue to serve Justin and have money come in? And then as you know in white collar cases, like even with that call from my co-defendant, the hedge fund manager, like nothing happens for two months. You don’t realize, we have people in our community get sentenced three, five, seven, eight years later. They have kids. They become grandfathers. You don’t understand the timeline. So I just figured they sort of forgot about me. But I was just focused on me during that window.

Alex: You said you were focused on you. Was it the money that was driving you? Because you weren’t married at the time.

Justin: No.

Alex: Right? You had no kids. So what was sort of your North Star at this period? It had been success building your career, you know, in investments. What do you think was driving you at that time to make the kind of poor decisions?

Justin: I got lazy. I had one client. I built my business cold walking into offices along Ventura Boulevard. And I raised 10, 20, 30, 40 million, not by cold calling, just by cold walking, going to rotary clubs and speaking, presenting, selling, bringing in money. And then one client began to make up so much of our business, this one client, a hedge fund manager. It’s like, well, if I work more, does it really matter if I make 740 this year instead of, you know, 550, together with what he produces and other clients? So I became reliant on one client, which is sort of a problem. Then, it wasn’t so much the money, because I had some investments, I had my home, I had nice things. I like the acknowledgement and the affirmations that came with working at Bear Stearns and being successful and having that look of success. And I really wanted to maintain that. And I would argue when I got into trouble and I was going through this fallout, part of the reason I lied was because I didn’t wanna be viewed as a criminal. I admire someone like you. You’re a lawyer. You’ve done it the right way. You’ve built a business. And I didn’t want to look differently in the eyes of someone like you. So I did all I could to maintain that facade.

Alex: Which is so dangerous. The desire to maintain the facade is so dangerous in these situations, ’cause it often is totally counter to what you need to do.

Justin: We tell people, like, you became a lawyer to help people. And there’s nothing that you have not heard at your stage of the game.

Alex: No, that’s true.

Justin: But we’re ashamed, and we don’t wanna be looked at… That’s why I lied to my lawyers. I had great lawyers. It was very easy to blame my lawyers until I went to prison and walking that track in prison. A lot of lawyers blame the lawyer, the judge, the prosecutor. It’s very hard to look in. So I had great lawyers. They tried to help me. I couldn’t really give them an opportunity to help me. When you lie, you blame other people. You tell them half-truths. You excuse. If I flush money down the toilet with lawyers, it was my fault, because they were doing their job. It was all on me. And that was my pattern for a long time. But to answer your question, I liked others thinking that I was successful at 27. It was very devastating when that image was destroyed.

Alex: And I think it’s so interesting because that is, for the people in this world who are, you know, facing these sort of white collar investigations and investments or doctors or lawyers who get in trouble, they’ve been successful. They’ve sort of got that golden ring. They don’t wanna let go of it. And so what you’re describing is so common to the clients that I work with, that they don’t wanna admit the truth. They don’t want to acknowledge the shame about what’s going on. And you’ve obviously taken that journey and gotten to the other side.

Justin: You have to, like, share more than you could even consider sharing. I didn’t, like, really embrace and understand that. If I wanted to say something, I needed to go, like, times 10 and share it with my lawyer. Like, if you think it’s bad, share it. That’s the only way they can defend you, because it’s heartbreaking when my probation report came back and it’s like, “Well, a lot of this stuff isn’t true. They’re gonna ask him for, like, 10 years in prison. This is insane.” Then it’s sort of like, well, did you prepare for that? Did you prepare for that interview? Your character reference letters are terrible in part because people love and support you, but you haven’t really opened up about what you did. You haven’t accepted responsibility. You haven’t earned the letter. And it requires, like, introspection and being able to say, “Even though I didn’t have bad intentions, I hurt people. I created victims. I’m ashamed. And rather than talk, I’m gonna try to build a record that proves how this will never happen again.” You’ve got to demonstrate resilience.

Alex: 100%.

Justin: Amy had that resilience through her platform. I did not. Too many defendants do not.

Amy: Well, going back though, I think one of the things that I have found in speaking to people who have been through this journey, the doctors, the lawyers, the traders, is that, like, I think it can be hard to comprehend that somebody viewed what you did as a crime. Like, you might think, “Okay, at best, what I did is…”

Justin: Morally ambiguous.

Amy: Like, morally ambiguous, but, like, the business world is morally ambiguous, right? And so maybe there will be some lawsuits, but that’s that. And, like, a civil lawsuit is a very different thing than criminal charges. You know, you said you talked to the lawyer and that UBS was going to be in these lawsuits. And it wasn’t that you were working alone either. Like, I have to imagine other people on your team.

Justin: Sure. My senior partner maintained his job, but he and I were still talking. We weren’t supposed to. It’s another thing. Co-defendants are people with whom you shouldn’t. But it’s comforting. You wanna listen, and you wanna listen to them. You don’t realize they could take that information and run to UBS or run to the government. That is so incredibly common. So there were myriad people. What gave me comfort was UBS was gonna scratch the check. And I felt they were somewhat culpable because I went to compliance. What I didn’t understand was the timeline and how I so easily could make matters worse. Like, when I met with the FBI the 20th of April, or a month after they showed up at my home, I didn’t know. What you know now, when people hire you, they probably know most things. They’ve interviewed people. They’ve gone through text messages, emails. They’ve studied the documents. They’ve spoken with people. They probably know 90% of just about everything. And I didn’t understand how much work had gone into that meeting. I was very naive. So they asked me questions. And it’s one thing to say, “I don’t recall,” or, “I don’t know.” It’s another thing to flat out lie, which is what I did.

Alex: But did you lie because at the time you knew that what you had done was a crime?

Justin: I didn’t know that it was a crime at the time. I didn’t embrace the term. You may know lawyer David Willingham. He was the prosecutor in my case. He’s a big lawyer right now in Los Angeles. And we’ve had conversations over the years, we’ve had clients over the years, and it was in prison that I read this term, like, willful blindness, which is what I tried to have them have me plead guilty to, like, turning the other way. And David said, “It wasn’t just that. Certainly, you turned the other way in some meetings so people could invest in your client’s hedge fund, and you can continue to make money on the trades. There’s no doubt you kept your mouth shut. But you also did this. You gave credibility and credence to your client that he hadn’t earned. You gave him the warm and fuzzies that he was a client of UBS, and that gave comfort to his clients to invest. You have to understand how that is conspiracy.” And I’m like, “What is conspiracy?” I remember reading and looking up. So I didn’t really understand until I went to prison. I found a mentor, a friend, my friend Michael Santos, who served a quarter century in prison, who helped me understand how my actions were criminal. And then you walk that track in prison, thinking, “Wow,” had I responded differently, worked openly with my lawyer and the government, you know, perhaps I wouldn’t be in prison and enduring the fallout, and really the pain to my parents, which is just terrible.

Amy: Did it surprise you to learn that willful blindness was a crime?

Justin: It did, and then, of course, you read the statute and it’s like, well, you know, not saying anything is just as effective as saying something. It’s like, oh, that really makes total sense. And then I have two children, 8 and 12, and I’m like, “Wow, they’re the king and queen of willful blindness.” You know? But it’s different.

Alex: The 8-year-old.

Justin: It’s different at home. It’s different when you’re a 26-year-old or 28-year-old executive, and you’re supposed to know, right? So if you accept the responsibility of being a licensed stockbroker and working at Bear Stearns or UBS, and getting the bonus and the money and the accolades, you can’t claim, “I didn’t have the experience,” or, “I didn’t know.” It just doesn’t work.

Amy: Well, and there’s even a crime, you know, outside of the financial world, which I’m sure you know, called misprision of felony.

Justin: Yes. I wanted that, too.

Amy: And that is a federal crime of not reporting a felony that you witnessed.

Justin: Well, it’s funny you mention that. So when I was called into my branch manager’s office at UBS, an investor in my client’s hedge fund had sent a fax to my branch manager inquiring into this investment. This accountant was managing, helping manage money for one of my client’s investors, and he sent a fax to my branch manager that sort of said, like, “Is this true?” He was inquiring into the return or performance of the hedge fund. So clearly it wasn’t true, because this fax said that my client’s hedge fund was making, like, 27% a year, and he lost every dollar. So that’s when I tried to, like, blow the whistle. I’m like, “That’s it. I don’t wanna work with this guy anymore.” It’s just not comfortable for me to work with this guy. Like, how do we get rid of him?

Alex: A little over the edge.

Justin: It was too late. Yeah, that ship had sailed, so to speak. And I just liked the commissions. I had grown somewhat accustomed to them. And you rationalize it or sleep by telling yourself, “He manages the money, not me.”

Alex: Well, rationalization in these sorts of cases is just always present.

Justin: It’s the hardest part, and part of what I convey to people when they come into our community who will say, “I felt pressure.” We saw this during the COVID case. We had more than 100 people retain White Collar Advice through the pandemic, and many of them would say the same thing. “I’m in California. The governor shuts down the state. I felt pressure due to the pandemic. I needed revenues. I didn’t wanna leave staff.” So you have the pressure to make money, the rationalization, and the opportunity, of course, to submit these loans. And then I’m like, “I can understand the pressure, but do you understand, I…” Just as a former prisoner and trying to learn in this space, I’ve been to 1,500 sentencing hearings. When I was in the halfway house in Hollywood, I would use my passes not to think about eating or I just got out of jail, I wanna have sex. I’m like, “I’m broke. I gotta do something.” I would have my mom pick me up, drive me to the courthouse, and I would watch sentencing hearings. And I would hear Judge Wilson, who sentenced me, Judge Gee, and others say, “I understand you faced pressure, and you might have rationalized it, but do you recognize how many Americans faced that same pressure who didn’t have the education and opportunities that you did, and don’t cheat?”

Alex: They don’t make that choice.

Justin: “That doesn’t work in my courtroom.” And that’s the power of looking inward, and saying, “There are no excuses.” And I just didn’t know how to convey that message as a defendant. I just didn’t know how to do it, and rationalizing, you’re right, is the hardest, ’cause you can look at yourself in the mirror and you know you’re lying. You just see it. And then you focus on the good that you’re doing, not the bad.

Alex: Self-delusion is rampant in these cases.

Justin: That’s why you need truth-tellers in your life. You need a lawyer who says, “Look, I’m gonna treat you like I would my own son, and I’m gonna help you. And I’m gonna get paid for it ’cause I’m good at it. But let me help you understand how decisions you’re making are gonna get you closer to what it is you don’t want, standing for count for five years instead of three. And I can’t predict you won’t stand for count for five years, but you’re making decisions that are going to get you there.” Like, I needed, like, a right hook across the face. I needed that, and I actually believe my lawyers tried. I had great lawyers, Bob Corbin and Joel Athey.

Amy: How did you find them?

Justin: So, I had originally hired Jones Day, and I couldn’t afford Jones Day. And about three or four months in, and it was a great break for me, ’cause I couldn’t have afforded them, Jones Day said, “We’re conflicted, because we also represent UBS in some matters.” And I said, “Okay, what does that mean?” And it was actually, I believe, it was a U.S. attorney, Jeff Robitz. He suggested to me Bob Corbin and Joel Athey. Bob is a former public defender in New York, had never been a prosecutor. And I reached out to them, and Bob kinda took me in. He spoke to me very directly, and he said, “If you go to trial, I won’t be the one taking you to trial. You can’t afford it, and you’ll lose. That won’t be us.” And I said, I’d learned a little bit more about fee structure. I said, “I just can’t afford the hourly rates of Jones Day.” That was a mistake as the civil lawyer had sent me there. And they did their job. It was me. And he said, “Okay, well, we’re gonna offer you an inclusive rate.” I’m like, “Well, what does that mean?” He said, “You’re gonna pay one fee, and that’s going to cover everything through sentencing.” I said, “Through sentencing?” And that’s when he would begin to talk to me and say, “You are pleading guilty. You may get sentenced to prison.” And I would hear these terms playing dumb, like, “Oh, I still may get sentenced?” Right? That’s sort of where I was at that point. So I hired them with a flat fee, and to the extent that they could help me, they tried. But I told half-truths and denials and excuses all the way until I surrendered to prison and began to work on telling my story.

Alex: Those truth-tellers you’re talking about, it can be a lawyer, but I’ve also seen it can be a family member, it can be a spouse. It can be, you know, a parent. I think if you have that sort of truth-teller in your life and you’re a defendant or a target, you’re just so much better off.

Justin: You need several of them.

Alex: You need a support system, really.

Justin: The problem is some people, you tell them what you want them to hear, then they enable the conduct. And they say, “I can’t, but this is a travesty,” and they end up telling you, confirming exactly what you think should happen. And it makes matters worse.

Alex: I hear spouses all the time tell these just fantastical stories about how their husband, usually it’s their husband, but how their spouse isn’t guilty. It’s so important to cut through that and say, “No, I need you to understand what they need to understand as well.”

Amy: I wanna talk about what you do now, because it’s so interesting. You’re an expert in a world I didn’t know existed before my husband faced a DOJ investigation. So can you talk about your business?

Justin: To understand the business, I have to take you to prison.

Alex: I pass.

Amy: I don’t wanna go there.

Alex: I go enough as it is.

Justin: That’s enough. So I was ultimately sentenced by Judge Wilson to 18 months in federal prison. He said something like, “I’m tired of salesmen turning the other way for money. Most don’t get caught. You did. I’m gonna make an example out of you and send you to prison.” My co-defendant got five years. And he went to Lompoc. And my lawyer said, “Well, we’re gonna ask for Taft Camp, because he cooperated against you. They’re not gonna send you to the same prison.” I’m like, “Where is Taft?” And it turned out to be about 30 or 40 miles west or east of Bakersfield. Cool. So I surrender April 20th, 2008, three years to the day after the FBI shows up. And on the drive to the prison, my mom and brother drive me. I’m maybe 30 pounds heavier than I was now. I have the final prison meal, like the cookies and the Carl’s Jr. at the gas station. I’m eating like I have a date with the death penalty. It’s like the electric chair. No joke. Then I surrender. I get adjusted, and then my second day in, Michael Santos, who you know, comes and says, “How you doing, young man?” I said, “Not great. Just got here for 18 months.” He said, “I’ll serve every day of that sentence with you.” And he had been inside for 22 years. Including eight years in the penitentiary, and had educated himself in prison. Got an undergraduate and master’s degree, wrote a great book called Inside: Life Behind Bars in America. We were in the same dorm, and he tried to mentor me in those early days, but I didn’t really take the advice. I adjusted to prison like a lot of people do through exercise. Like six, seven, eight hours a day on that track.

Amy: That’s what you’re doing. You’re just walking.

Justin: That’s it. And then several months into my career, to begin to answer how the business began, I told Michael, I said, “Dudes are scared to go home. Lawyers, doctors, dentists, entrepreneurs, like they’re freaking out at a visitation because their wife asks them, ‘How are you gonna make money?’ And some have gotten some disciplinary infractions, I think, enough to lose some good time.”

Like, what are they doing? And he said, “Well, do you think you’re any different? You may exercise all day. You might not watch television all day, but you kind of have the same routine. You just presume ’cause you went to USC that everything is just magically going to work out.” And he said, “You should understand the result of that adjustment in prison.” And I said, “Well, I wanna do something better.” And he said, “Well, why don’t you think about helping other people for once? Why don’t you think about providing value for once?” It was the greatest lesson that changed my life, because with his help, October 12th, 2008, unbeknownst to me at the time, I didn’t know it would start this business, Michael helped me write my first blog. There was no email at the time in prison, so I hand wrote it with his help, and I sent it home to my mom. And he said, “At the end of this blog, you said you’re gonna make a commitment to write every single day. Can you fulfill that?” I said, “I can try. Do my best.” He said, “There is no try,” like Yoda. “There is no try. You do.” I said, “I will, but I’m gonna need your help.” And it’s sort of the message that we tell people who come into our community. We give everything away through prisonprofessors.org. Our nonprofit that does work in every BOP prison. Michael’s visited 90 federal prisons over the last two years. There’s 10,000 people on the Prison Professors website documenting their journey, 20 million words. If you can use all of our free stuff and do it, do it. You don’t need to hire White Collar Advice. It’s all free. I fund it. I needed a guide, so Michael was my guide, so I hired him with what little resources I had left to help me with my daily blog, and that blog eventually became my first book he helped me write called Lessons From Prison. But the value was kind of back when you asked me earlier, was it the money that I was making? I like the affirmation. So I’m writing this blog from prison, and I would begin to get letters at mail call, people thanking me for reading the blog. “Hey, my mom is going in,” or, “My dad’s going in. Thank you for providing a glimpse into this world of imprisonment.” So I would run into Michael’s cubicle and be like, “Dude, I got eight letters today.”

And he said, “That’s a really good data point for you.” I write prolifically. Some of these white collar defendants are writing you instead of me, and no one has more knowledge than Michael Santos. Perhaps they’re writing you just ’cause they identify with you as a stockbroker serving 18 months. So the business began because Michael said, “I encourage you to begin writing. Try to provide some value.” Then with that feedback, it led to Lessons From Prison, and it was his idea to establish White Collar Advice with revenues that I bring in helping support the nonprofit Prison Professors, which it has till this day, and he had four years left to serve.

Amy: And so what do you do with White Collar Advice?

Justin: So White Collar Advice will help defendants through all phases of a government investigation, not as a lawyer. I’ve never dispensed legal advice once, but helping them understand perhaps the government’s version of events, the timelines that could follow. If the government’s working full time to advance their agenda, what is success for a prosecutor? What is success for a judge? What can you do today to begin to change that narrative?

Alex: That first step that you mentioned, I wanna go back to it because I think it’s so important and people ignore it. If you don’t take time to think about what the other side of the courtroom is doing, what they’re thinking, how they view you, how they view the case, no sort of strategic step you can ever make is going to be successful. You have to understand what they think of you, what they think of the case, how they’re investigating the case. You talked about the fact that they kind of know everything. In a white collar case, they probably do. It’s easy to follow the money, but so few defendants, and sadly so few lawyers, actually take the time to consider what’s happening on the other side of the courtroom.

Amy: Well, an easy way to describe it too is, like, watch the tape, right? Like, you’re a college baseball player, you know. Like, if you’re going into a baseball game, you’re gonna watch the game tape. You’re gonna figure out how the other side plays.

Justin: That’s right. One of the first questions we’ll ask: Let me ask you, how would the prosecutor in your husband’s case describe your husband? Right now, if he’s having a cup of coffee somewhere…

Alex: Which one? There have been about 12.

Amy: Well, there were many.

Justin: But go back many years ago.

Amy: I think at the beginning they would’ve described my husband as, like, a shifty real estate developer or, like, a not honest guy. Like, that was the narrative that they had.

Justin: We encourage people to embrace the perception. Now, I’m not saying you’re gonna be able to change that perception or perspective.

Amy: But maybe you can.

Justin: Maybe. Well, that’s what we encourage people.

Alex: Sometimes you get lucky.

Justin: Just try. I’m sure you may get this too. We get calls from people who are like, “I’ll work with your team if you could get this outcome.” I’m like, I can’t change the past. I can’t predict the future. If I could, I wouldn’t be doing this. What I encourage you to do is begin to build some record because I can assure you it doesn’t end at sentencing. Even if you get what you want, probation or home confinement, the collateral consequences of being a convicted felon can actually be harder than the time in prison. Banking, reputational, finances, licensing. Like, to the extent that you can show what you’ve learned from it, perhaps how you’re an asset to an employer or a funder or a spouse, or, in my case, I got married after prison. My wife judged me based on who I was striving to become. It’s not as important. Forgive me for saying this, the sentence matters, but with First Step Act and Good Time, even RDAP, like, sentences aren’t the length they were when I was in prison thanks to prison reform.

Alex: They’re, luckily, much more reasonable. They’re still unreasonable.

Amy: But, like, we’re talking about figuring out the other side…

Justin: You’ve got to invest the time. You have to put yourself in their shoes and create a message. And I tell people, “Even if you don’t get the outcome you want, was the effort wasted?” Because look at what you’ve developed. Look at what you’ve built, right? Even if, God forbid, at some point your family doesn’t get the result you want, you have such an online library of content and documentation for your children, for your future. Someday, I tell people, when I’m dead and gone, if my kids or their grandkids, they can look back and say, “This is how my dad or grandfather chose to respond and wanted to help people,” it’s all documented. There’s value there. Even if you get a longer sentence.

Alex: Be proud of how you walk through the process. And what’s interesting about this is we’ve been focused on folks who have committed the crime, who have done the offense. I mean, we have a lot of clients who are wrongly accused, or they drop the case, they dismiss charges, they don’t bring charges. That’s happened with Amy’s husband. They don’t bring charges at all. Or we go to trial and it’s contested, and we win or maybe we don’t. What’s interesting is I think for those individuals, as much as the folks who absolutely did it and need to find the sort of best path out, I think the answer is still be proud of how you go through the process. Because if you know in your heart, and your lawyer’s telling you, you didn’t do that thing, I think for some people walking through that process and fighting is that same sort of message of I’m standing up for what I believe in. In the same way that really taking responsibility for the bad things you’ve done is equally sort of important if you clearly have done this bad thing.

Justin: I think that’s exactly right. I know that some people, we end up making matters worse as a defendant. We just don’t know that we are, and it’s often hard to say, if you have done it, “I failed. I hurt people. I created victims. I didn’t intend to end up here. I’m here.” For people in our community that go to trial, I filmed an Instagram video recently where I said 90 people in our community had gone to trial and not one of them had won.

Alex: I watched this video just with like, “Ah.”

Justin: And a journalist is like, “Well, how do you deal with that?” I’m like, “Well, I’m not the trial lawyer, and I don’t think it’s the trial lawyer’s fault either, in part because some people who go to trial are probably guilty.” I have no doubt others are innocent, but as I described in that video, it comes back to what we just discussed. I read a great book, Blink, by Malcolm Gladwell, and he discusses this idea of thin slicing, that the second I walk in here, we form judgments of one another, right? There is no doubt when my wife told her father that I was gonna marry some guy that went to jail, he probably formed an opinion that maybe her daughter has low self-esteem and there’s something wrong with her that would marry a dude out of jail. We’re forming opinions. So the argument as a jury is probably forming an opinion if the government chose to say, United States of America versus this person’s name. It’s much more difficult to prepare someone if they truly feel that they are the victim or being harmed. ’Cause I can say, “I did it. I earned these consequences.” I know you’re maintaining your innocence, but it doesn’t change. You still have an obligation, as Amy did, to lead through the injustice, to share lessons, and to somehow emerge stronger. Because if you don’t, they get not just your finances, they get your mental health and it could define the rest of your life.

Alex: We had P.G. Sittenfeld on a few weeks ago. He obviously fought through trials, always maintained his innocence. He went to jail, and he wouldn’t have if he had pled guilty. I think they were gonna give him, you know, no jail time. But I think he had a great sort of line about that, “That’s just not who I was. I wasn’t going to just sort of say I did this thing I didn’t do.” He wasn’t capable of standing up and pleading guilty to something he hadn’t done. But I think it’s the same lesson for a target, whether your case is bad and you’re likely guilty, or you really have a strong case and you didn’t do this thing and you’re gonna fight. You have to focus on how do you show up in that moment and be the best version of yourself.

Amy: When I think about this now, for most people, if you find yourself in the spotlight of a government investigation, there hasn’t been a time in your life when some other actor or entity has a light on you and is writing a narrative and is writing a story. And for me, when my husband found himself under investigation, that was certainly his experience. No one had ever been writing things about his life or cast a light on him. I had a different experience as a public-facing entrepreneur, and I knew what it was to have a narrative said about you and to have a story written.

Like, I was cast in the role when I started The Riveter as, like, pregnant founder who can raise money. Like, literally, that is how the media cast me. Like, every story written about me was about that.

And I’m like, “It’s kind of boring. Like, I can do other things.” But that was the story. And I saw very quickly with my husband, like, the prosecutors would have a view, and the media would have a view. There was a story. And so part of it for me was like, well, if we don’t answer that, the story is written. But if you don’t have that experience, it’s hard to jump in and realize that.

Justin: So something that you did, well, you went all in, right? You followed what I said earlier, like go all in, consequences be damned.

Right. You absolutely did that. There’s two things. One, if you plead guilty and you don’t think you’re innocent, I get these calls from prison. You get them too, I’m sure. “I spoke with a jailhouse lawyer, and he’s gonna review the case, and I should have gone to trial.” Like, my God. And then they convince themselves they are more the victim than ever…

Alex: Ignoring the choice that they made or the agency they had at that moment.

Justin: Correct. And then their prison term oftentimes can become a waste, so they reach the end of their prison term with a whole new set of regrets over, what am I going to do now? I’m not naive. No one wants to be in prison. But a camp is not the penitentiary where Michael served eight years walking through puddles of blood. Okay? There are opportunities for growth, for creation. Michael helped me build this entire business through there, the nonprofit that raises a few million dollars a year and influences millions of people. He began engineering when he went to prison in ’87 from the penitentiary. All of it is possible, but if you waste the day… The great thing about complaining is eventually you’re gonna get your turn. And I cannot have people reaching the end of their term calling me from the halfway house like, “Oh, my God, they won’t approve my job. They want me to work at KFC.” And I’m like, “Well, dude, you have no plan that demonstrates what you’ll do moving forward. You owe $7 million. They need $100 a month. No, you can’t go work for yourself as an entrepreneur. You haven’t built a record that shows why they should allow it. You’ve spent too much time ruminating on the fact you should have gone to trial.” There are a lot of injustices, however, like 20 or 30 people in our community who have been indicted. They say they’re gonna go to trial, and they indict the spouse as well, which compels the defendant to plead guilty, only to keep the defendant out of…

Alex: It is the most unethical piece I’ve ever seen.

Amy: Can we just pause on that for one second? Because I think people who have never watched this system, their mind can’t comprehend this. Like, it happened to me on a level. When the government was investigating my husband, there was one moment where they’re like, “And here’s this tax prosecutor, and Amy Nelson signed these tax returns.” And luckily, our CPA was like, “Their tax returns are fine.” And he vouched for them.

Justin: I mean, in your experience, I know you have a lot of friends who are prosecutors. So do I. But is that the biggest thing that you have seen, overcharging, in your experience?

Alex: No, I mean, there’s plenty of overcharging. We had a rule when I was there, and Brent Hannafan, who I work with now, is the crim chief, the don’t charge the girlfriend rule. And that sort of extends to wives as well ’cause you’d have these big drug cases, and the DEA would come in and say, “Okay, here are these three…” And we’d ask, “Who are these three people?” And they were the three girlfriends of the three main guys. Like, “Well, we have them on surveillance. They were there for a deal,” or they did this or that. And I just thought, what’s gonna happen is the case is gonna plead out. You’re gonna have those three people go to trial, and it’s just not a just case. There’s so much you don’t know about the dynamics of that situation. The idea that those folks are as culpable or worthy of federal prosecution was just nuts. And it was done because, one, you either wanted to pad the stats, ’cause you wanted to add these numbers to our indictment, it’s a 10-person indictment instead of a six, or you wanted to coerce a plea. And I think as a prosecutor, if your case isn’t good enough and you can’t do what you need to do without coercing, without coercing a plea, you’re not doing your job. And so it is one of the ways that they overcharge. It is one of the more sort of unconscionable ways. I’ve never understood it. I think it’s just completely a sign of weakness for a prosecutor who says, “All right, if you wanna go to trial, we’re gonna go charge your wife.” It’s just nuts.

Amy: There are all these unjust things that can happen in the system. Like from your perspective, what are some things that we could change or that we should be fighting to change?

Justin: If you have seven years, you should build a documented record at prisonprofessors.org with journal entries, biographies, book reports that show why you are a candidate for freedom. Earning freedom. We’d like to see parole come back, where if you get 10 years, in three years you go in front of a parole board and say, “Look at the record that I’ve built. I am earning my way home. Review my time-stamped record.” It ain’t talk, what I intend to do. Part of the problem is some people embrace the wrong message. Sometimes people misconstrue our messages. And here’s what I mean. I filmed this video recently where someone called after sentencing. He’s like, “I’m really disappointed in you guys.” I’m like, “Well, we haven’t spoken before. Well, who are you?” “I’m really disappointed. I’ve read all of Michael Santos’ stuff.” “The judge didn’t love my letter.” I’m like, “Well, read me the letter.” And it mimicked everything that Michael Santos wrote. And the problem is people don’t know what to copy, and it was, “I wanna live as a law-abiding, contributing citizen. I wanna use my experience as a tool to help other people. I wanna influence millions of people in prisons and jails.” I’m like, “That is a really great message. The problem is you actually haven’t done any of that.” And I used the line from the movie Straight Outta Compton, where Ice Cube had said to someone, you know, “Wearing a Kangol hat doesn’t make you LL Cool J.” Writing a paragraph about becoming a law-abiding, contributing citizen and helping millions of people doesn’t make you Michael Santos. There’s no record behind it. And in the age of AI, where a computer can make you look like a genius in six minutes, if you have a judge that follows through and questions what you say you are doing and you haven’t done it, it actually makes matters worse because it confirms how they see you, as a shortsighted person not willing to do the work. So it can be more hazardous than it actually can be helpful. If you pled guilty and created victims, do you identify with victims? Are you laying out a vision of how this will never happen again? Are you getting into life circumstances that a judge should hear from you? Like when did you begin working? What are your values? Do they align with the judge’s values? Why will you never return to another courtroom? Too many engage in cliches and platitudes. “I’m sorry. I wanna make amends,” and there’s no meat behind it, or they focus on themselves.

Alex: Yeah, I think what you’re talking about is for so many folks in white collar cases, it’s fraud. There’s some sort of deceit. There’s some sort of lie. There’s sort of misdirection or just background lack of truth, right? And so when you present them sort of a journey of how you can kind of get a better result or you could improve yourself, I think too many of them just believe, “Well, I can just fake my way through this, too.” And it’s not about faking your way. You can’t fake it till you make it. You have to actually show up in a genuine way to get the results of people believing you’re actually remorseful. I’ve had clients I’ve been standing next to, reading letters to the judge, and the words are fine, but the emotion and the real sort of impact of that falls flat because they don’t believe it.

Justin: And there’s no evidence behind it. Not to stroke your ego, years ago we had a client together. I won’t mention his name. And I said, “Well, why is he a good lawyer?” And he said, “Well, you said something in a video.” He found me through a video I filmed called, like, 12 Questions to Ask a Lawyer. And he’s like, “He doesn’t have a God complex. He’ll listen to me. He may not agree with me,” for reasons that you just described. We’re not lawyers. Many would call me a prison consultant. I served one year 17 years ago. I’m not an expert in prison. I teach through lived experience and really what Michael did. Those are the lessons we teach, but there are occasionally some lawyers who will say, “No. I don’t need your feedback. I don’t want your opinion. If I need your opinion, I’ll give it to you.”

And I liked when he said he doesn’t have a God complex. He’s willing to listen to me, which also means you’re willing to push back if it’s the wrong message. Because you bear the responsibility if things go rogue. It’s not me.

Alex: No. The lawyers that I think just do it, and we’ve done videos on this before. The worst sort of white collar lawyer is the one who says, “Listen, I’ve been here. I know what’s best for you. I know what’s gonna happen. I’m the expert. Just do what I say.” And we get so many clients who are on their second and third lawyer.

And so we have to hear that story of all the ways the lawyers have gone bad. But the number one issue is the lawyer unwilling to engage with the actual sort of truth of what the client wants to convey. Because it’s really difficult. You have to be patient for all the reasons we’ve talked about. People in the situation don’t wanna tell you the truth. They wanna tell you half-truths. They wanna sort of manipulate the lawyer just like they’ve manipulated the victims. And so as a lawyer, if you are gonna show up and be patient, it’s really hard. You know?

Justin: It can be. I absolutely agree with that. I know we get a lot of defendants who think it ends at sentencing. And they’re so fixated on the number.

And they don’t understand how the probation report can influence not just the sentence, but life in custody and programming and when you come home on probation. My lawyers, to the extent that they could, helped me understand it. We want people to know this isn’t so much a mitigation strategy. It is a life strategy.

And we tell people there is no guarantee you’re gonna get exactly what you want, but if you begin to build, the effort isn’t wasted. I can’t predict what’s going to happen.

Alex: But isn’t that life? You’re not guaranteed to get home tonight, right?

Justin: Yes. I mean, I’m not guaranteed to get home to my little girl’s event tonight in Los Angeles or Orange County, okay? And I think you’ve got to be willing to do the work as you did, through uncertainty, through failure, through terrible criticism, through embarrassment.

I still to this day will post videos or say something and think, “How could I have said that? I wish I did it differently. I’m getting criticism, but I’m principled. I’m trying.” And the reason I’m able to do that, I think, is ’cause I started 17 years ago with help from a mentor in prison. You can’t just wait a week before sentencing or three weeks and try to make up for weeks and months and years of bad planning. One of the worst cases we ever had was a chiropractor in Arizona whose case took five years, and he said, “There’s nothing for me to do ’cause I’m gonna get a mandatory minimum of two years for identity theft.” So, he ended up getting a longer sentence ’cause the judge essentially said, “I don’t like that you bought a Tesla, and you went on a vacation. I’m not giving you the mandatory minimum of two years.” Even though it was 30 months instead of 24, who cares?

Amy: That’s six months of your life. Yeah.

Justin: It was the reality that he wasted five years doing very little to begin building this new record. Then the sentencing comes, and he’s like, “Well, what should I do next?” And it’s like, “That’s why you’re not working.” That’s why when you call people out of the blue, they’re like, “Dude, you’re trying to use me. I haven’t heard from you for…”

Alex: “What do you mean? You want me to write you a letter for you? I haven’t talked to you in years.”

Justin: “What are you doing? You’re using me. There’s an opportunity you’re trying to seize.” So if they can create something every day, if they can build something every day, if they can cultivate one new contact a day to the extent that they can every single day, their life will look different. But they can’t take the bait if they pled guilty and say that they were a victim. They really need to do as Michael taught me to do, like work on your message. Introspect. Learn to tell it. And like we said earlier, share more. Acknowledge what you did ’cause as human beings, we make bad choices. I think more judges and case managers would appreciate this.

Alex: I think that’s so fascinating about the work that you do sort of shepherding defendants through the process, through sentencing and after sentencing. What we do as lawyers, a lot of it is therapy. I mean, what you’re really talking about is sort of how to lead a better life. How to be a better version of yourself. And it’s not just the, “I’m gonna teach you some tricks to the criminal justice system.” It’s not just, “As a lawyer, I’m gonna sort of navigate these legal, you know, curves.” It is really, today you have some choices to make about how you’re gonna show up in the process. There are choices you can make that are gonna help you and choices you’re gonna make that are gonna hurt you. And you have to make good choices every day. And better choices every day.

Justin: I think the reason you’re successful, and the top lawyers, they embrace that rather than, we’re gonna come in and play lawyer and negotiate a plea. I have never negotiated. I have filmed videos where a defendant’s like, “I’m negotiating a plea. Will you look at it?” I’m like, “I would if I had a law degree, and I went to law school. I’m not in a position to do that. I can help you understand how not working openly with your lawyer could hurt you.” Or continuing to talk to your co-defendants, or that you’ve spent the last three months on the couch doing nothing to build a message that could influence a judge. That’s how I can help you, but I ain’t looking at a plea agreement. That’s not what I do. So I think good lawyers help defendants see this doesn’t end at sentencing. This is a lifelong stain, and to the extent that you can begin to prepare for that, the better. I mean, even Prison Professors, I received a call from someone recently like, “Hey, I want a letter from Prison Professors for sentencing.” And I’m like, “This is some of the same behavior that kind of got you into trouble. We’re not gonna write a letter that says you did something when you didn’t, because we do work in the BOP, and it’s gonna influence a judge. But if you’d like to do something, we would love your help. You have an MBA.”

We need help with tech. We wanna get to 50,000 profiles. How can you help? Why don’t you be like Gerry Lundrigan or Daryl Cohen and others who create something with us that we then get into our curriculum that teaches people inside of prisons and jails that shows that people are developing skills. Like, get vested with us. Help us, and when you do, you’re absolutely gonna get that letter. Come home and volunteer for the nonprofit. That could be your job in the halfway house. But it’s not gonna happen by you saying, “Here’s a check, and I’m gonna get a letter.”

Alex: But that’s exactly what Santos told you that first sort of week in jail. You’ve gotta start thinking about how to provide value to other people.

Justin: It’s the greatest lesson he gave me. I was a self-centered, entitled, arrogant guy in jail who was the victim. And what I didn’t realize is I had parents sending me commissary every month. I had friends that visited me every Friday. I was young. I had an education, a brain. I still had some money left. And I didn’t appreciate the people around me, the real struggle. There’s this story. One time Michael and I were in the quiet room. He would get in there at 1:00 in the morning. I would meet him there at 5:00. And one time someone’s walking up the steps, and he said, “JP, what could that person be someday?” And admittedly, it was someone who was maybe in his 40s, 80% of his body tattooed. And I said, “Well, maybe a janitor or something.” He said, “Why can’t he be the CEO of a company? ’Cause he’s got tattoos? ’Cause he’s been in prison for nine years? Do you know what he does every single day? Do you see him writing in the library? Do you see him writing his children? See the programming? Did you know that he has an online journal that he shares with his network? Do you know people right now are advocating for clemency for him? And you look at him and presume he can just be a janitor. He can own the company.” So he helped me understand that people could become anything or become the CEO, as he would say, of their own life. But you can’t ask people to do what you haven’t done, and that is our message at Prison Professors. I’m not gonna ask you to write a narrative or release plan or build an online journal. You can’t ask a woman to overcome crisis if you yourself haven’t done the work. You’ve got to do the work. That’s the only way that someone can really advocate for you.

Alex: It’s the credibility of learned experience.

Justin: He taught me to do that. That is our message: we’re never gonna ask you to do what we haven’t done. And by doing that, you live with more dignity in prison. You’re more productive because you’re learning, you’re building, right? Even reading. I used to read books, and sometimes I’d avoid Michael ’cause I’m like, “I can’t answer his questions. This is terrible.”

Alex: I don’t wanna do this today.

Justin: And he’d say, “What book did you read?” And I’d say, “What book I read.” And he’s like, “Why did you read it? What did you learn from it? How will it help you moving forward?” And I couldn’t. And he’d say, “Here’s what I want you to do. Tomorrow come in at 5:00.” And this is what we do with people in our community. Even if you have an MBA from Yale or Harvard, okay? ’Cause when you go through crisis, people, they struggle to respond. “Meet me here tomorrow at 5:00. We’re gonna go through a detailed note-taking strategy. And every book for the rest of your life, I suggest, why did you read it? What did you learn from it? And how will it help you moving forward? You are going to write a book report.” Of which I’ve written hundreds and so has he. Well, the knowledge I began to obtain from those books enabled me to help build this business, ’cause Michael still had four years left to serve when I was released. My probation officer wouldn’t let me visit him. There was no email yet in prison.

Alex: ’Cause he’s, quote unquote, “still a felon.”

Justin: He’s in prison. And I’m on probation, and I’m doing this with, frankly, a lot of help from his wife Carol. But I began to read deliberately with a purpose, and that helped me become smarter, and the prison term was productive.

Some guys would mock me, because they would say, “You’re a tourist. Your sentence is so short. You know, why is Santos helping you?” And Michael would say, “I will help anyone willing to do the work. I’m in here at 1:00 every day. You’re free to come in and get guidance from me. I teach the class in the warehouse Monday and Tuesdays, the Entrepreneurial Compass. You are free to come in, but you’re not gonna work harder than me, and I’m preparing to come home after 26 years.” I was willing to do the work, but sometimes it was hard serving time with him because he’s so deliberate. Everything is, “What is the result we want?” It’s hard.

Alex: Excellence is difficult to be around. I’ve had opportunities as a lawyer to work with truly excellent lawyers, and you realize that there’s no shortcut. Nothing replaces hard work. And hard choices and that sort of consistency, you can’t fake it. And so sometimes that’s difficult to be around, right?

Amy: It’s exhausting.

Justin: It can be, when you’re around someone that’s so authentic that actually did the work. And, you know, even today he’ll say, it’s like, “What’s the result of the podcast today? What are we hoping to do here? Are you just gonna talk about the JP stockbroker story, you went to prison? Are you gonna talk about how we wanna change this system that makes failures of so many?”

Alex: But you’re talking about intentionality. It’s living life intentionally.

Amy: And with that mindset, you can use some of the hardest things you go through whether it’s dealing with the fallout of committing a crime or dealing with, you know, false accusations, as the greatest clarifiers in your life.

Justin: Well, what Michael helps me do in the nonprofit is the idea that we can all become better than bad decisions of our past. And there’s certainly gonna be people that will always judge us. People judge me for people with whom we work, people who write on the Prison Professors website. And Michael helps me understand: Justin, there are 10,000 people writing at Prison Professors. Some of them are serving life in prison for murder. They are documenting their journey. They are striving to become better, and if they do, they may get rewarded inside of that prison. Someone in a high, based on the record they’re building for a terrible crime, may drop to a medium, and that’s in the interest of the Bureau of Prisons, ’cause it costs less to warehouse them. And at some point, most people don’t have a life sentence, and they’re gonna come home, they’re gonna return to their community, and you can’t just give someone a job if they don’t find value in work. Prison Professors, regardless of the crime, helps people build a new record, and that gives me strength and comfort and confidence when someone says, “How can you work with that person?”

Alex: There’s two pieces, right? It’s that they can be valuable to society and they can help others, but also they’re human and worthy of respect. Amy and I, we’ve talked about this a few times, we met working for former President Jimmy Carter. And I don’t think there was a human on this planet who lived the sort of Christ-like idea that all humans are worthy. The work that I did with him, we would go, mostly in Africa, and negotiate with warlords who had done terrible things to try to end a conflict. And so these are people like Joseph Kony, who is still at large, who is just one of the most notorious sort of warlords of the last 30 years. Muammar Gaddafi. You know, he met with Gaddafi multiple times. He went to North Korea during the Clinton administration to try to negotiate a nuclear sort of resolution there. And his position always was, “You have to talk to people even if you think that they are evil or terrible or do bad things. Because, one, they are humans, and you have to at least connect with them on that level. And two, if you don’t allow for that connection between individuals, nothing’s going to improve ever.” And so, you know, no matter how notorious a defendant is in prison, as a lawyer, as a prison consultant, as someone who’s trying to do good things in the prison community, you can’t write people off, because that’s exactly how we get the bad situation we have. We just throw people in a hole and say, “Good luck.”

Justin: There’s a sense of humility and perspective that comes through this. When I was a target, I continued to lie and I made matters worse for myself. I also did terrible things as a stockbroker. So part of our business is you find the good, you recognize we can’t change the past. You can do better moving forward, not through talk. When I was released from prison, I would use my passes in the halfway house to both go to sentencing hearings, and I would cold walk with my book, Lessons From Prison, into law offices in downtown Los Angeles. And my second four-hour pass, I wore the suit that I was sentenced to prison in. It was like, I looked like a freak because I’d lost like 30 pounds. But I didn’t have the money, or the tailor said I should throw it in the trash. So I’m wearing this huge suit, and my mom drove me downtown. I had two and a half hours. And I would, I’d get past security, and I would walk into offices. And lawyers would throw me out. They wouldn’t shake my hand. They’d say, “You weren’t welcome. You weren’t invited. I don’t know you. Are you stupid? Don’t you see the no solicitation sign?” One lawyer threatened to call my probation officer, and I remember looking in the mirror on the 10th floor at 333 South Grand thinking, “My God, they hate me. This isn’t what I expected it to be.” I felt a sense of dignity that I was trying. Only one lawyer that day shook my hand. His name is Mark Werksman, who’s been a good friend for 16, 17 years, a good lawyer. So I share this story with you because it was always my dream that lawyers would welcome me into their office, want to hear my insights, ways that we could collaborate and work together. And even 17 years later today, with this invitation, and the hundreds of lawyers with whom we work, it’s sort of an affirmation that even though I was thrown out that day, the effort was worthwhile. So I’m really grateful that you invited me in today.

Alex: Well, thank you so much. We’re glad to have you.

Justin: Thank you.

Get each episode when it drops

Sent from the TARGET Substack. Subscribing also signs you up for Amy Nelson’s newsletter. Both are free, and you can unsubscribe from either anytime.

Latest · EP 08From Lying to the FBI to Helping Targets Avoid His Mistakes
0:00